Page 1 of 1

Lily Trees???

Posted: Aug 21, 2008 11:33 am
by Chris_W
Ugh, not another crazy marketing ploy to lure in the unsuspecting, inexperienced gardener :eek: Someone came in the other day and asked if I had any lily trees. They said this was the latest breakthrough from Spring Hill...

Yes, leave it up to Brecks, Gurney's, Michigan Bulb and Spring Hill to come up with the trademarked "Lily Tree" to describe what are nothing more than oriental x trumpet hybrid lilies. Sure some of these might get taller than some other lilies, but please, they DO NOT GROW INTO TREES! On top of that, the varieties they list aren't even the tallest lilies you can buy. :hmm:

However, I love this bit from the Spring Hill website: ..."stems that reach up 3-4 feet the first year, 5-6 feet the next year and upwards to 6-8 feet in three years! It’s almost like planting a lily flower shrub!" Okay, so it's a Lily Tree (TM) that is not quite like a tree, but almost a shrub :lol:

Please people, don't fall for marketing gimmicks like these. They are oriental x trumpet hybrid lilies. Beautiful plants, but not trees, and they are not unique to just these companies :roll:

Re: Lily Trees???

Posted: Aug 21, 2008 9:37 pm
by John
Chris, you gotta love that your posting was followed by a Spring Hill advertisement!

Re: Lily Trees???

Posted: Aug 22, 2008 11:24 am
by nanny_56
But there are people who will believe that c**p no matter how many peolple tell them different!

Re: Lily Trees???

Posted: Aug 24, 2008 7:44 am
by woodthrush
At least Michigan Bulb corrected their site. Last spring, the had the 'lily tree' listed as a species of magnolia and pruning instructions!
Pam

Re: Lily Trees???

Posted: Aug 27, 2008 10:36 am
by LucyGoose
OMG!!! I think I will copy your post and pass it on to the gardening club people, if that's okay........I think some have mentioned still ordering from Michigan Bulb, if I am not mistaken..... :roll: I try to get them to log in here to learn, but hey......only one......*Lucy waving to lurker Elaine!!* :lol: ... :wink:

Re: Lily Trees???

Posted: Aug 28, 2008 8:58 pm
by eyesoftexas
i HAD TO LOOK TWICE....CAUSE I KNOW THERE AIN'T NO SUCH ANIMAL.... :lol: